I've often railed out (into the wind, it seems) that "writing is writing," that the differences among the various "kinds" of writing are insignificant. I pretty much want to make the same protestation that "music is music" with the same message in mind. However, rather than expand on this latter truism, I want to venture another, perhaps more controversial, equation, namely that "music is writing" and "writing is music"!
Oh sure the "grammar" of each is expressed in different terminology, but they mean the same thing.
Both use symbols as the basic mode of expression (words and notes) and rely on an underlying structure (grammar and notation).
The basic elements of music are melody, harmony and rhythm.
The basic elements of writing are genre, story and meter.
An engaging sentence (in any kind of writing) has a lyrical quality that blends in with the message being conveyed and does so with a satisfying accented.
An engaging riff (in any kind of music) has a stylistic quality that expresses a purpose in the piece as a whole and does so with a satisfying beat.
So, can any good writer be a good musician -- and vice versa? Hmmmmm.......
Oh yes...I forgot...these siblings only share one parent. The other is unique to each: music has the ears and writing has the eyes. Their common parent? The brain!!
Writings, Musings and Detritus on Politics, Alternate History and Science Fiction by Robert G. Pielke ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Why bother reading this blog? Good question...glad you asked! You will notice that all of my comments, arguments, critiques and opinions are expressed LOGICALLY. My academic profession is a professorship in PHILOSOPHY -- with a specialty in LOGIC! I'm doomed to do it no other way.
BOOK ACCESS -- CLICK ON THE BOOK COVERS
Click on the following book covers on the right to go to their specific sites:
1. You Say You Want A Revolution: Rock Music in American History
2. NEW (2nd) EDITION: Rock Music in American Culture: The Sounds of Revolution
3. A New Birth of Freedom
4. The Mission
5. Hitler the Cat Goes West
(You can buy many many copies from theses sites -- via Amazon.com.)
Want some free selected short subjects? CLICK BELOW
5. Bob Pielke's Shorts
1. You Say You Want A Revolution: Rock Music in American History
2. NEW (2nd) EDITION: Rock Music in American Culture: The Sounds of Revolution
3. A New Birth of Freedom
4. The Mission
5. Hitler the Cat Goes West
(You can buy many many copies from theses sites -- via Amazon.com.)
Want some free selected short subjects? CLICK BELOW
5. Bob Pielke's Shorts
The Mission
The Greatest Science Fiction/Alternate History Ever Written. Ok, it's in a niche of a niche of a tiny genre…but you won't find a better example of its kind anywhere! [including Harry Turtledove] It has been said that the combination of science fiction, alternate history and time travel is a risky endeavor. So be it!
You Say You Want A Revolution
The Greatest R&R Book Ever Written! Who says this, aside from me, of course.....? Click on the cover and see why! SOON TO BE UPDATED AND REPUBLISHED BY MCFARLAND AND COMPANY PUBLISHERS, INC!
Wednesday, December 30, 2009
Music & Writing: Siblings With A Parent In Common
Posted by
Bob Pielke
at
6:15 AM
Labels:
genre,
genres,
harmony melody,
literature,
meter,
music,
musicology,
notation,
pielke,
rhythm,
style,
writing
| Reactions: |
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
0 comments:
Post a Comment